• Oakland Roots
  2 - 1
  Indy Eleven

• Memphis 901
  1 - 2
  Indy Eleven

• Indy Eleven
  1 - 1
  Sacramento Republic

• Indy Eleven
  1 - 2
  Detroit City

• Louisville City
  5 - 3
  Indy Eleven

• Indy Eleven
  2 - 4
  Charleston Battery

• Colorado Springs
  1 - 1
  Indy Eleven

• Indy Eleven
  2 - 1
  North Carolina

• Chicago Fire II
  0 - 1
  Indy Eleven