• Charlotte
  1 - 0
  New York City

• St. Louis City
  2 - 0
  New York City

• New York City
  1 - 2
  Portland Timbers

• New York City
  2 - 1
  Toronto

• Cincinnati
  1 - 0
  New York City

• Inter Miami
  1 - 1
  New York City

• New York City
  1 - 1
  Atlanta United

• New York City
  2 - 0
  New England

• New York City
  1 - 3
  Philadelphia Union

• New York City
  2 - 2
  SJ Earthquakes

• Portland Timbers
  0 - 0
  New York City

• New York City
  1 - 0
  LA Galaxy